skip to Main Content

In a Pretty Box Review: A New Subscription Box for Women

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something. Please check out our privacy policy for more details.

In a Pretty Box is a new subscription box for women. All of the products included in each box will be handmade, which may explain why you’ll pay a premium for this box. A subscription costs $42 per month, and shipping will add an additional $9 to your order, so this is definitely one of the pricier boxes out there. (Though I’m told a sample box is coming that will cost $15 per month!) I would most compare this box to the PopSugar Must Have Box, or even My Ireland Box, in that it contains full-size products that would make good gift items for women.

Here’s what I received in my June In a Pretty Box:

Mint Nail Polish

Mint Nail Polish in Dirty Shirley ($12) – I’d never heard of Mint nail polish and I’m always glad to find a new polish brand! ย The color I received, Dirty Shirley, is gorgeous and I’ll be painting my nails this color immediately as soon as I’m forced to remove my Astrowifey manicure.


Sage K and Co. Leather Cord Bracelets ($14) – How does one properly photograph bracelets on her arm? This is a skill I obviously don’t possess! These leather bracelets are cute and will go with everything.

Tickled Peach Studio Note pad


Things To Do Notepad by Tickled Peach Studio ($14) – I’d actually been in the market for a new notepad since I’ve taken to using random scraps of paper that I find around my computer. This notepad is super cute, although if I’m being honest I never would have paid $14 for this!

Noella Beauty Eyeshadow

Noella Beauty Mineral Eyeshadow Samples ($12.99) – I’ve never tried lime green eyeshadow before so I’m excited to see if it’s my color. ๐Ÿ˜‰ These are very generous sample sizes, and while I’m not certain I’d regularly use these colors I can’t wait to see how they look.

Hand-painted mini bowl

In a Pretty Home Hand-Painted Mini Bowl ($8) – This tiny bowl is probably my favorite item that was included in the box. It has earned a place of honor on my night stand, so it can hold on to all of the jewelry I forget to take off each night before bed. ๐Ÿ™‚ The mint color is gorgeous and it’s just a really cute item even if it isn’t really practical for much besides holding jewelry.

The value of all of the items I received in this box was $60.99. Not bad, although since this box would cost $51 (including shipping), I would expect a box of this value or higher.

As for whether I would recommend In a Pretty Box or not, it totally depends. If you enjoy receiving full-size handmade treats each month and have the income to spend, then sure. This was a lovely box and I will surely use all of the contents! However, I think the box would be better if it came down at least $10 because spending over $50 for a box is daunting. $25 is usually the price point where I think twice about a casual purchase, and spending $50 on a treat box is something I’d have to budget for each month. Where I do think this box would be nice is as a one-off gift for someone – perhaps as a thank-you, or as a house-warming gift.

What do you think about In a Pretty Box? Would you be willing to spend $50+ for this box?

Disclosure: While I was provided with a box to review, all opinions expressed above are my own.

This Post Has One Comment
  1. Hello everyone!

    I’m Tiffany, owner and founder of Pretty Box. First of all, thank you so much Lisa for reviewing our monthly box. I just wanted to pop in to let your readers know that through Monday the 22nd we are having a free shipping weekend with code: free at checkout. We run specials every few months, so readers can sign up for our newsletter and receive updates on discount codes.

    As of today, we are also able to securely accept all major credit cards– checkout is completely secure and PCI compliant– as well as Paypal.

    We are also debuting our sample sized box at $15 with shipping included on August 1.

    Thank you so much for partnering with us, and we hope you and your readers enjoy our handmade products!

Comments are closed.

Back To Top
Close search